health fitness

Tommy John Second Skin Review - The $38 Underwear That Changed My Mind About Premium Pants

★★★★☆4.4(12,000 reviews)

By MikeUpdated 2026-06-18

Affiliate Disclosure: BargainTop10 is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely believe in.

👖

Tommy John

$37.99

Check Price on Amazon →

⭐ Our Verdict

Best premium underwear. At $38/pair, it is 4x the price of Hanes. But the comfort difference is real. Buy 3 pairs for rotation and they last 2+ years.

✅ Pros

✓Modal fabric is unbelievably soft
✓Quick Draw Fly (horizontal opening) is genius
✓No-roll waistband stays in place
✓No ride-up legs (stay-put silicone)
✓Moisture-wicking for workouts

⚠️ Cons

✗$38 for ONE pair of underwear
✗Modal fabric pills after 12 months
✗Quick Draw Fly takes getting used to
✗Some prefer cotton (modal is synthetic-feeling)

I thought $38 underwear was absurd until my wife bought me Tommy John Second Skin. After 1 day, I ordered 4 more pairs. The modal fabric is softer than any cotton underwear I have worn. The Quick Draw Fly is actually useful.

Tommy John vs Mack Weldon vs Saxx

Tommy John: softest fabric, Quick Draw Fly, $38. Mack Weldon: Airknit fabric, no special fly, $28. Saxx: BallPark pouch (keeps everything separate), $32. Tommy John for comfort. Saxx for support. Mack Weldon for value.

Cost Per Wear

$38 / 100 wears/year / 2 years = $0.19 per wear. Worth it.

Check Price on Amazon